On GLBT Month & Discrimination
I was going to continue on with the normal GLBT month postings today and post an interview or excerpt or something of that sort. I'll get back to that tomorrow. I just had my eyes opened a little yesterday on how bad things can be out there for GLBT teens and tweens. (For anyone not in the mood for a long semi-rant, you can skip this post).
First off, let me explain one thing about myself. I am never for censorship (even if I disagree with a book or author), discrimination, intimidation, or hate language. I have no patience for those things. If you want to restrict your own child from reading or watching something, it is your right (though I don't necessarily recommend or understand it, depending on the situation and age of the child), but it is NOT your right to force your beliefs on others.
In my personal life I am happily married. I've had gay friends over the years and never considered anything about them to be "abnormal" or even "different." Maybe that's a product of being a reader -- when you open yourself up to new experiences, new lives, etc., you broaden your own life. And while I've never experienced what it feels like to be a gay person (or, for that matter, a black person or a disabled person or a foreigner living on American soil), I have experienced prejudice in my life (being half-Asian and living in the South, you soon learn that the remnants of the KKK don't like you either and that people will actually drive from all over the county to check out the "weird new Chinese people" that just moved to town).
But enough about me -- here's the situation that prompted this post. Yesterday, I posted to a message board on Teachers.net inviting teachers to come check out GLBT month at YABC and explaining that I had a bunch of books and teacher guides to give away. I wasn't at all prepared for the torrent of hate and name calling that my post started up.
I was particularly surprised because these people are teachers. These are the people that are out there in our schools teaching our students -- many of whom happen to be gay, bi-sexual, lesbian and transgendered. These are the people to which someday I'll be trusting my own child.
You can read the string of posts here. I'm not sure how long it will stay up, but I find that I seem to not be welcome, even though I did not engage in any name-calling of any sort. I tried to post a response to some of these people and explain a few things (that I believe these books most emphatically do belong in schools and that they aren't pornographic smut), but my post seems to have been rejected. Meanwhile, one teacher did post a more moderate view and other (often anonymous) posters continued to heap on abuse. Yes, that's right -- they don't even have the courage to sign their name to their posts. Not all of them, of course, some did.
So, what am I trying to say? Well, to any teens or tweens out there struggling (or not) with your sexuality, I feel for you. I'm sorry and I hope against hope that the people around you are NOT like the teachers who posted on Teachers.net. I hope that you will find your own path and your own way and will find support among your peers. I hope that you will find books like the ones being featured this month and that the authors who write them will keep on writing them until there is no such classification as "GLBT" lit -- when books featuring GLBT characters will be mainstream enough that no one even thinks twice about it.
And to any teachers out there reading this -- no matter what your personal views are on GLBT people, I hope that you will realize that YOU are teaching them out there every day and that you will stop to consider your words and your actions. I know there are many excellent, non-prejudiced, non-hateful teachers out there and to them, I say "Thank You." I hope that YOU will enter the contests. I'd really love to have these books and teacher guides out there getting some use in capable hands.
And another huge THANK YOU to the authors out there who are writing the books and breaking down the walls.
--------------------------------
Update as of 9/17: I was getting copied via email on all of the responses to the thread and woke up this morning to find a number of well-reasoned, non name-calling posts contributed by a new teacher. So I went to the board to post a thank you but found that the admin (presumably) had chosen to delete ALL posts related to the thread. I find it most disheartening that they did this not when people were posting really ugly comments, but when someone posted reasonable ones. They made no attempt to stop some really nasty name calling, but as soon as someone posted messages that were the least bit supportive of discussion, the whole thread was gone. If they were concerned about the hate language, they could have just deleted those posts. I'm not sure exactly what their reasoning is, but it certainly makes it appear as if they condone something that, frankly, leaves a bad taste in my mouth.


18 comments:
I read all the posts to that site. What is sad to me is that the people posting didn't consider the fact that you were offering books. They only saw the "GLBT" and freaked out. Most of their comments are about the subject matter and not the fact that there is good literature out there for teens that makes them want to read. Whether they are gay, lesbian, or straight... they are reading and we teachers should encourage that. I, for one, am glad there is quality literature for my middle school students that is realistic and meaningful. Thank you for keeping the teachers in mind with your book prizes. I am very disappointed in some of the members of my profession for taking a stand on their personal beliefs instead of taking a stand for their students.
Kimberly, I'm sorry you experienced that tirade of hatred and homophobia just for posting about GLBT books! Sometimes it's hard to believe how full of hate and fear people can be. And it's pretty scary that those people were teachers--I'd hope for more compassion and understanding from people who work with children and teens....
I wanted to say thank you so much for having a GLBT month. It's so very important for lesbian, gay, bisexual and trans readers to find books that reflect some of their own experiences, or just accept them--and important, too, I believe, for heterosexual readers to read (when the books are written well) so that they might gently open up to and become more accepting of the people in their lives who are lesbian/gay.
Sometimes the homophobia is incredibly disheartening, or painful...and then someone like you helps make it a bit--or a lot--better, by helping to provide resources and show all the wonderful books that are out there. If this helps even one isolated or lonely lesbian/gay/bi person, or one straight person accept us more, then you've done an amazing thing.
Thank you. I know I'll be poring through your lists and reviews, looking for books I haven't read yet. :)
I hope you guys will definitely enter the contests. I've been surprised that I've rec'd so few teacher entries. Though after all the "storm in a teacup" I went through on the site, maybe I shouldn't be surprised. Many of the teachers that aren't prejudiced against GLBT people seem to be afraid. That just makes me sad.
Hi,
Sounds like we folks at GLSEN have our work cut out for us. Teachers are one of the main problems in many schools which have no programs on respecting differences.As a teacher I see examples of teachers a actually
encouraging bullying tacticts by students.Scary isn't it?
Kim,
This is such a great thing--the GLBT month. It's very hard to know what to say about the reaction of teachers who just spin out when the term is even mentioned. I guess, sadly, it's not that shocking. We hope for so much more from teachers--but teachers are people, and lots of people have that reaction.
But the more things like this--the GLBT books month--happen, the more good and positive things people do, I can't help but believe that the tide will turn. It's only a question of how soon.
Hooray for GLBT YA books! And hooray for you!
-Maureen Johnson
Oh, that's so awful!
The only good thing I can think of now is that every poll shows that, generally, teens have a much more open-minded and welcome attitude about gay people than adults. I really think that things are getting better every year and will continue to improve. It seems that today's teens can teach their teachers a lot right now.
I'm speechless.
I'm really saddened but wish I was more surprised by your post Kimberly. Like you, I don't really think about this issue, believing that GLBT and older folk are part of the community the same as all races etc.and when I encounter this kind of intolerance it makes my gut churn. Having children of my own who are teens and are at school every day I often wonder at the hypocritical nature of the educational system and the way fabulous, meaningful and enriching books are banned or just ignored because people are scared of the content or scared of the backlash. But as Debby Garfinkle has said here-(WTG Debby- love your work!)I've also noticed that they and their wonderful friends dont let it affect them as much as we think! The teens themselves find ways of keeping their minds open and thankfully there are many more places where wonderful books can be obtained covering all kinds of topics than just the school library.
Don't let it get to you.
Have great day!
Elle
As a lesbian mother with a son just starting preschool, the reaction to your post horrifies me. I was delighted to let my readers (mostly lesbian moms) know about your event, and I hope some of them visited. There are a lot of common bonds between LGBT youth and the children (LGBT and not) of LGBT parents.
Thank you for all that you are doing to promote acceptance and understanding.
Thanks so much everyone. It's good to know there are reasonable people out there!
I hope you'll keep spreading the word -- I've still got over 150 books to give away this month! Anyone of any age can enter (from tweens to teens to adults to grandparents). And since I've had almost no teacher entries (I'm so sad about that), I might be giving away 1 - 5 instead of 1 - 3 in the other giveaways.
As a student teacher, I hate that this happened to you. Unfortunately, some people who are in the profession don't have the ability to empathize with or support their LGBT students. While I would be extremely careful about having LGBT-related themed books in my classroom due to the fact that I live in Virginia's "Bible Belt" and I would be afraid of losing my job, I would never express negativity or hatred about those books! While I'm a straight white girl, I understand what it's like to not fit in when you're in high school, and I think books featuring LGBT characters are a healthy thing for ANYONE who feels different or needs to know that it's OKAY to BE different.
Kim,
I went to Teachers.net and found nothing on GLBT. I'm sure they have censored - I mean deleted any reference to GLBT month. I did place a post with the librarians - who I hope are more open-minded on this issue than many of those classroom teachers. Below you will find a copy of my post - in case Teachers.net censors it - or chooses to not even let it run.
Rebecca Frager
Library Media Specialist
Woodlawn High - Baltimore, MD
What's with the discussion on the GLBT and Kimberly Pauley? I went to check out her posting and anything related to GLBT Month, her postings and all the responses have been deleted!
I believe this is a topic worthy of honest and open discussion. As a high school librarian, I serve all children in my school, whether straight, gay, bi, transgendered, male, female, Asian, Black, White, Muslim, etc.
Each and everyone of these children deserve to have books wherein they can "see" themselves. The books they read need to be real to them, present real issues, deal with real situations. The books need to mirror their lives so they can learn, grow, expand and develop their minds.
Censoring honest discussion about Gay and lesbian issues is paramount to burying our heads in the sand. We are saying this issue is just something we don't want to deal with - even though our kids deal with the intolerance and hatred everyday.
I'm saddened and disappointed that Teachers.Net has decided to "censor" discussion on these issues.
LibraryLady
Thanks, LibraryLady, I think you said it well. We'll see what happens :-)
And I seriously do encourage all of you to enter the giveaways as well -- if you win, keep the books, pass them on, share them, whatever you like. I'd like to get them out there.
I'm so sorry this happened, especially since you were doing something positive and supportive for the community.
I am proud to be a new reviewer for your site, and I hope you continue doing what you're doing.
Kimberly, I didn't get to see the posts, but I am so sorry this has happened to you. As an author whose books deal with contemporary realistic topics, I am often called upon to consider topics like whether teens still discriminate against homosexuals, HIV sufferers, etc., like they did when I was a teen. I am always sorry to see evidence that, yes, they do. If the teachers aren't coming out against this attitude, how will the students ever learn to be more tolerant?
I hope your event is great
In the interest of restoring everyone's faith in public school teachers, I want to report that I spent the last three years in a VERY conservative part of the country doing my best to advocate for GLBTQ kids in my classroom and school. Not only did I come down hard on students who used homophobic language in my classroom, but I also worked with my colleagues to help them understand that regardless of their religious or moral beliefs, it is our job as teachers to make sure that every member of the educational community (students AND teachers!) is safe at school.
My students -- 7th and 8th graders -- had some awesome discussions about discrimination and hate in general, and homophobia specifically. We talked about homophobia in conjunction with issues of Otherness in The Giver and discrimination in The Diary of Anne Frank. My students researched issues of hate and peace in connection with topics such as Martin Luther King, Jr, Matthew Shephard, the Birmingham Church bombing in 1963, Columbine, Ghandi, Tienneman Square, Coretta Scott King, and more.
Take heart! While it's true that there are a lot of small-minded teachers out there, there are also a lot of teachers working to promote diversity and tolerance in our classes.
Molly B.-- I am truly grateful for teachers like you.
This saddens me SO much. I was planning on featuring a bunch of GLBT books for National Coming Out Day on my blog, and I can't believe in this day and age, we'd have this aminosity. Especially from teachers. Which begs the question...if a child is open about their sexuality in their class, how does the teacher react?
I actually wrote about my sexuality in an English paper of all things and my professor was warm and receptive and honored I'd share with her.
I love the idea of the GLBT month. Thanks for doing it!
Post a Comment